greeksoup/ stock research

Murphy USA Inc.: Q4 FY2025 earnings call

What management said about Q4 FY2025, from the documents filed with the SEC on 4 February 2026: press release. Guidance figures: 10 new. The quarter’s numbers.

Key takeaways

  • Net income flat, EPS up in Q4: Q4 2025 net income was $141.9 million, or $7.53 diluted EPS, against $142.5 million, or $6.96, a year earlier. Full-year net income was $470.6 million, or $24.10 per diluted share, against $24.11. Source
  • Retail fuel margin rose in Q4: Retail fuel margin was 31.0 cpg in Q4 2025 against 28.9 cpg a year earlier. Full-year retail margin was 28.1 cpg in both 2025 and 2024. Total fuel contribution was 34.3 cpg against 32.5. Source
  • Merchandise contribution up for the year: Q4 merchandise contribution was $213.2 million, up 2.1%, on a 19.6% unit margin against 19.9%. Full-year contribution rose 4.2% to $869.0 million, on a 20.2% unit margin against 19.8%. Source
  • Store operating expenses up $14.8 million: Store and other operating expenses were $281.3 million in Q4 and $1,108.5 million for the year, driven by net new stores, employee costs and maintenance at existing stores. Source
  • 2026 guidance issued with assumptions: Management said the 2026 ranges include stated assumptions and are subject to the uncertainties it noted. Source
  • Buybacks of $652 million in 2025: Q4 repurchases were 175.4 thousand shares for $67.5 million, at $384.65 average. Full-year repurchases were about 1.5 million shares for $652.0 million, at $424.28 average. Source

“Fourth quarter results were strong across the board, underscoring the strength of our operating model, our continued focus on efficiency and execution against our organic growth goals for the year”

President and CEO Mindy West

Guidance

AreaPeriodFigureAgainst last quarter
New-to-industry stores Source202645 to 55New
Raze-and-rebuild stores Source2026up to 30New
Retail fuel volume per store (K gallons APSM) Source2026233 to 237New
Retail fuel volume per store, same-store change Source2026(3.0)% to (1.0)%New
Merchandise contribution Source2026$890 to $900 millionNew
Store OPEX excluding payment fees and rent (K APSM) Source2026$37.0 to $38.0 thousandNew
SG&A Source2026$240 to $250 millionNew
Effective tax rate Source202623% to 25%New
Capital expenditures Source2026$475 to $525 millionNew
Illustrative net income and Adjusted EBITDA Source2026net income $439 million; Adjusted EBITDA about $1.0 billionNew

What changed from last quarter

  • New guidance: 2026 guidance ranges are issued in this release for new stores, fuel, store profitability, corporate costs and capital expenditure. Source
  • New: Mindy West is to become President and CEO on January 1, 2026, and to join the Board on that date.
  • Ended: Andrew Clyde's CEO tenure of 13 years ends, with his retirement from the Board on December 31, 2025.

Quarter and full-year results

  • Net income flat, EPS up in Q4: Q4 2025 net income was $141.9 million, or $7.53 diluted EPS, against $142.5 million, or $6.96, a year earlier. Full-year net income was $470.6 million, or $24.10 per diluted share, against $24.11. Source
  • Adjusted EBITDA higher in both periods: Adjusted EBITDA was $290.9 million in Q4 2025 against $278.3 million, and $1,019.4 million for the year against $1,006.8 million. Source
  • Fuel and merchandise lifted the quarter: Management said the quarter benefited from higher fuel and merchandise contribution, driven by higher retail fuel margins, higher fuel volumes and improved merchandise sales. Source
  • Store costs and interest offset gains: Offsets were higher store operating expenses, G&A, depreciation and amortization, interest expense and income taxes, which together reduced net income slightly. Source
  • Full-year decline driven by store costs: For the full year, net income declined mainly on store and other operating expenses, depreciation, interest and restructuring, partly offset by merchandise contribution and lower tax and G&A. Source

Fuel margins and volumes

  • Retail fuel margin rose in Q4: Retail fuel margin was 31.0 cpg in Q4 2025 against 28.9 cpg a year earlier. Full-year retail margin was 28.1 cpg in both 2025 and 2024. Total fuel contribution was 34.3 cpg against 32.5. Source
  • Management tied margin to volatility: Management said retail margins were 2 cents higher than the prior year, as higher levels of market volatility were introduced. Source
  • Total gallons up, same-store volume down: Total retail gallons rose 3.1% in Q4 2025 while same-store volumes fell 0.6%. For 2025, total gallons were flat at 4.8 billion and same-store volumes fell 2.6%. Source
  • Low-price offer resonating with loyal customers: Management said its low-price offering continues to resonate with loyal customers, and expects flat per-store volumes in 2026, with new-store volume offsetting a nominal decline. Source
  • RIN income rose in both periods: RINs in other operating revenues were $55.3 million in Q4 2025 against $38.6 million, and $211.7 million for the year against $129.6 million. Source

“The business has overcome a challenging first half in 2025 to deliver strong full-year results, demonstrating the resiliency of our strategy, reflecting the tireless efforts of our dedicated team members, and providing incredible momentum as we enter 2026.”

President and CEO Mindy West

Merchandise and customer trends

  • Merchandise contribution up for the year: Q4 merchandise contribution was $213.2 million, up 2.1%, on a 19.6% unit margin against 19.9%. Full-year contribution rose 4.2% to $869.0 million, on a 20.2% unit margin against 19.8%. Source
  • Nicotine and non-nicotine moved apart: Nicotine contribution fell 1.5% in Q4 2025 while non-nicotine rose 4.6%. For the full year, nicotine rose 5.8% and non-nicotine rose 2.5%. Source
  • Same-store merchandise sales moved little: Same-store merchandise contribution rose 0.4% in Q4 2025 and 2.3% for the full year, while same-store merchandise sales were 0.5% in Q4 and (0.3%) for the year. Source

Store operating costs and SG&A

  • Store operating expenses up $14.8 million: Store and other operating expenses were $281.3 million in Q4 and $1,108.5 million for the year, driven by net new stores, employee costs and maintenance at existing stores. Source
  • Per-store operating expense up 3.4%: Store OPEX excluding payment fees and rent per store was $36.1 thousand in Q4, up 3.4% from a year earlier, and up 3.1% for the full year. Source
  • SG&A up in Q4 on incentives: SG&A was $65.2 million in Q4 2025. Full-year SG&A was $231.5 million, $3.9 million lower on lower professional fees, partly offset by higher incentive costs. Source
  • Depreciation and amortization rose: Depreciation and amortization was $72.7 million in Q4 2025 against $67.2 million, and $276.8 million for the year against $248.0 million. Source
  • Restructuring charge in 2025: Restructuring expense of $12.6 million was recorded for the full year 2025, with none in Q4. Source

“Fourth quarter retail margins were 2 cents higher than the prior year, responding favorably as higher levels of volatility were introduced to the market.”

President and CEO Mindy West

Store growth and pipeline

  • Pipeline described as in great shape: Management said the new-store pipeline remains in great shape and that the company is well positioned for sustainable organic growth in the years ahead. Source
  • Raze-and-rebuilds reopened in 2025: Raze-and-rebuild stores reopened 3 in Q4 2025 and 23 for the year. One raze-and-rebuild is under construction at year end. Source
  • Q4 openings exceeded 50-store target: Management said 29 new stores were put into service in the fourth quarter, exceeding its 50-store target for full-year 2025. Source

2026 guidance and assumptions

  • 2026 guidance issued with assumptions: Management said the 2026 ranges include stated assumptions and are subject to the uncertainties it noted. Source
  • Merchandise growth guided at 3%: Midpoint merchandise contribution growth of 3% reflects new stores, raze-and-rebuilds and promotional initiatives, net of some expected headwinds. Source
  • Store expense per site modestly higher: Store operating expenses per site, before payment fees and rent, are expected to rise modestly, reflecting larger new stores, rebuilds and investment in people. Source
  • SG&A and tax rate ranges: SG&A is guided to rise 3% to 7%, to $240 million to $250 million. The effective tax rate is guided to 23% to 25%. Source
  • Fuel volume and store counts guided: Per-store fuel volume is guided to 233 to 237 thousand gallons. The company guides 45 to 55 new stores and up to 30 raze-and-rebuilds for 2026. Source
  • Illustrative net income and EBITDA: For modeling only, the release gives net income of $439 million and Adjusted EBITDA of about $1.0 billion. The company does not provide a range for either. Source

Capital, cash and shareholder returns

  • Buybacks of $652 million in 2025: Q4 repurchases were 175.4 thousand shares for $67.5 million, at $384.65 average. Full-year repurchases were about 1.5 million shares for $652.0 million, at $424.28 average. Source
  • Quarterly dividend at $0.63: The $0.63 dividend paid December 1, 2025 is $2.52 annualized and 18.9% above September. Dividends paid for the year totaled $41.5 million, or $2.15 per share. Source
  • Repurchase capacity remaining: About $291.9 million remained under the $1.5 billion 2023 authorization at year end. A further $2.0 billion sits under the 2025 authorization, expiring December 31, 2030. Source
  • Capex range for 2026: Capital expenditures were $432 million in 2025 per the table, while cash flow property additions were $439.6 million. The 2026 range is $475 million to $525 million. Source
  • Debt rose, cash fell: Long-term debt including finance leases was $2,163.6 million, up from $1,832.7 million, and cash was $28.9 million against $47.0 million. $183.0 million was drawn on the revolver. Source
  • Operating cash flow lower in 2025: Operating cash flow was $813.9 million for the year against $847.6 million, and $245.5 million in Q4 against $248.7 million. Source

Leadership transition

  • West's career at Murphy: West joined Murphy Oil in 1996, became CFO and Treasurer at the 2013 spin-off, and was elevated to COO in February 2024.
  • Clyde stays on as advisor: Clyde will remain a non-executive advisor through February 2027, to help transition his responsibilities to West.
  • Clyde's CEO record: During Clyde's tenure as CEO, the company expanded to 27 states and more than 1,770 locations, according to the October 2025 release.

Strategy and balance sheet

  • 50/50 capital allocation kept: The Board reaffirmed key elements of its 50/50 long-term capital allocation strategy in its October 2025 announcement.
  • Bonus depreciation funds reinvestment: Incremental reinvestment capital is expected to be funded from bonus depreciation tax benefits under the One Big Beautiful Bill.
  • Leverage target under 2.5x: The company targets long-term leverage under 2.5x debt-to-earnings while maintaining a conservative balance sheet through cash flows and credit facilities.

Coming up, as management said on 4 February 2026

  • Early 2027 stores may move forward: The wider 2026 new-store range allows for potential bolt-on acquisitions in target markets, or for pulling forward some early 2027 stores into the current year. Source

Figures management reported

FigureReported
Merchandise same store sales Source0.5% Q4 2025; (0.3%) full year 2025
Retail fuel volume same store Source(0.6)% Q4 2025; (2.6%) full year 2025
Store openings and closings SourceQ4: 29 opened, 1 closed; 2025: 51 opened, 8 closed
Store count Source1,800 at December 31, 2025
Inventory Source$413.0 million at December 31, 2025, against $401.6 million
Merchandise unit margin Source19.6% Q4 2025; 20.2% full year 2025
Retail fuel margin Source31.0 cpg Q4 2025; 28.1 cpg full year 2025

Risks management discussed

  • External: Lower Q4 PS&W contribution was attributed to inventory timing and pricing tied to market conditions. Source
  • Operational: Management cited larger new and rebuilt stores and normal cost inflation as drivers of higher store operating expenses per site in 2026. Source
  • Demand: Management noted shifting consumer preferences in a low-price environment, which it expects to persist in 2026. Source

Earlier plans management reported on

  • Not stated: The board said it intended to increase reinvestment locations from 2026 to strengthen the same-store base.
  • Not stated: Four acquired Denver sites were expected to reopen as Murphy USA locations before year-end 2025. This release does not report their status.

Other quarters

Summarised with AI from the documents the company filed with the SEC. Every point is checked against the filing before it is shown: management’s own words word for word, figures against the line or table row they come from. A point that fails the check is left out. Source opens the filing at that line.